When Your Biggest Payer Is Your Least Profitable

Donna White

Donna White

By Donna White, Principal Consultant and Owner of Legacy Consulting Services and Legacy Billing Solutions in Montgomery, Alabama.

A high-volume payer can bring in millions in revenue while quietly cutting into your margins. For healthcare executives preparing their 2027 budgets, understanding payer profitability is key to making informed financial decisions.

Your largest payer may account for a significant share of patient volume and collections. But those numbers don’t tell the whole story.

How much does that payer actually contribute to your organization’s bottom line?

Reimbursement rates, payment accuracy, claim denials, and the cost of managing claims all affect profitability. A payer that generates high collections may also require more staff time, repeated appeals, and costly administrative work.

Strong healthcare finance strategies look beyond revenue totals. They consider what it takes to collect that revenue and whether payer contracts support the organization’s financial goals.

A payer profitability or reimbursement analysis can help healthcare leaders find payment gaps and avoidable costs. It can also flag contracts that need review before finalizing 2027 budgets. 

Why High Revenue Doesn’t Always Mean High Profitability

an image of a calculator and financial graphs with a stethoscope

Not all payer relationships bring the same financial value to a healthcare organization.

Consider two payers with similar patient volumes. One pays according to contract terms, processes claims on time, and requires little follow-up from billing staff.

The other pays at lower rates, denies more claims, and often requires calls, appeals, and corrected submissions before payment arrives.

Both may generate significant revenue. However, the second payer costs more time and resources to manage.

Several factors can affect how much a payer contributes to your bottom line:

  • Reimbursement rates: Do contracted rates cover the cost of providing services? Rates that once worked may no longer keep up with rising labor and operating costs.a
  • Payment accuracy: Does the payer reimburse claims according to the contract? Even small underpayments can add up across thousands of claims.
  • Claim denials: How often are claims denied, and how much staff time is spent correcting and resubmitting them?
  • Payment delays: How long does the organization wait for reimbursement? Slow payments can increase accounts receivable and create cash flow challenges.
  • Administrative costs: How much time do billing, coding, and management teams spend meeting payer requirements and following up on claims?

Looking at these factors together gives healthcare leaders a clearer picture of payer performance.

A full profitability analysis should also account for the cost of delivering care and an appropriate share of operating expenses. This helps distinguish revenue that looks strong on paper from revenue that truly supports the organization.

How to Evaluate Payer Profitability

an image of $100 bills and a stethoscope

A meaningful payer profitability analysis requires more than comparing reimbursement totals. Healthcare executives need to know what the organization gets from each payer. 

They also need to know what it costs to collect that reimbursement. 

They must confirm the contract supports the organization’s broader financial goals.

1. Compare Expected Reimbursement With Actual Payments

Start by evaluating whether payers reimburse claims according to the organization’s contracted rates and terms.

Compare expected reimbursement with actual payments across representative services, providers, locations, and procedure codes. Review contractual adjustments, payment variances, and recurring underpayments to identify patterns that may otherwise remain hidden in routine financial reporting. Separate unpaid balances from confirmed payment discrepancies. A claim awaiting payment is different from a finalized claim paid below the contracted amount. 

A payer may seem to meet expectations based on total collections. However, it may often reimburse some services below the contracted amount. 

These discrepancies can indicate a need for reimbursement analysis, contract compliance reviews, or more focused payer follow-up. The objective is to distinguish dollars still outstanding from dollars paid incorrectly—and identify which discrepancies warrant recovery efforts. 

2. Measure the Cost of Collecting Revenue

Collections alone do not show how much effort an organization must invest to receive payment.

Evaluate the administrative work associated with each payer, including claim submission, denial resolution, appeals, authorization requirements, payment posting, and accounts receivable follow-up.

Where reliable data are available, estimate the staff time and direct operating costs associated with these activities.

For example, a payer with a low denial rate may need little follow-up. Another payer may create repeated work across several departments. That difference matters when leadership is deciding how to allocate limited staff resources. 

The goal is not simply to identify which payer generates the most work. It helps determine if the work matches the reimbursement received, and if process improvements can reduce the burden. 

3. Examine Denials and Underpayments Together

Denial rates and reimbursement accuracy are related, but they measure different aspects of payer performance.

A payer may deny relatively few claims but still underpay for services it processes and closes. Another payer may reimburse correctly after it approves claims, but it causes extra administrative work. This happens due to avoidable denials and appeals. 

Review both patterns to understand the full financial impact.

Look for recurring discrepancies by payer, service, procedure code, provider, and contract. Determine whether the underlying causes involve payer processing errors, contract interpretation, coding, documentation, authorization, or internal workflow issues.

This distinction matters because the solution depends on the cause. Some problems require internal process improvements. Others may call for payment recovery efforts, contract clarification, or payer negotiations.

4. Assess Whether Contracts Still Support Financial Goals

Review a contract using today’s financial and operational needs. Do not accept it just because it is old.

Compare reimbursement terms with the organization’s costs, service mix, and financial objectives. Consider whether negotiated rates adequately support the resources required to deliver care and manage the associated administrative work.

Also review how contract terms affect reimbursement for high-volume services. Check whether patient volume or service mix changes have altered the relationship’s financial contribution.

A payer contract that was reasonable several years ago may no longer align with the organization’s needs. A detailed examination can help leadership determine whether to pursue payor contract negotiations, correct payment discrepancies, improve internal workflows, or explore other appropriate options.

5. Evaluate Payer Performance Within the Broader Financial Picture

Payer profitability should not be assessed in isolation.

Consider each payer’s performance alongside service-line margins, patient access, provider capacity, and the organization’s overall payer mix. A contract with lower reimbursement can still support important strategic goals. A high-paying contract may also have operational requirements that reduce its overall value.

Leadership should distinguish direct costs tied to a payer from shared expenses that are harder to allocate. Assigning overhead arbitrarily can produce misleading comparisons.

The goal is to build a defensible view of payer performance that supports better financial decisions. It will not rank contracts based on collections alone.

A Billing Integrity Audit Uncovered More Than $1.5 Million in Underpayments

Consistent payments do not necessarily mean accurate payments.

During a series of medical billing audits, Legacy Consulting Services identified recurring underpayments on high-dollar surgical procedure codes. The review found two causes: missing claim modifiers and wrongly loaded reimbursement fees for two providers in payers’ systems. 

The findings demonstrated why payment discrepancies require investigation on both sides of the transaction. Some claims required billing corrections, while others required the payers to correct their reimbursement configurations.

Across an 18-month period, the audit identified more than $1.5 million in underpayments. Working with the provider’s consultants, Legacy coordinated the preparation and submission of a claims recovery package to payers. The effort successfully recovered those dollars for the client over a four-month period. 

The engagement also led to quarterly claims audits, ongoing staff training, and continued monitoring. 

These steps help find more discrepancies and reduce the risk of them happening again.

This case shows a limit of relying on collections alone. Insurers can pay claims consistently but still pay them incorrectly. Identifying the underlying causes allowed the organization to recover revenue already owed and establish a process to monitor future payment accuracy.

Contract Untouched for More Than a Decade

In another engagement, a client’s payer reimbursement rates had not been renegotiated in more than ten years. The contract stayed in place, but its long history did not prove the rates still met the organization’s financial needs. 

Legacy Consulting Services successfully negotiated a 30% increase in reimbursement rates for the client. The result illustrates why payer contracts deserve periodic review rather than remaining unchanged simply because payments continue to arrive.

For organizations preparing their 2027 budgets, the question is simple. When were your major payer contracts last negotiated? What opportunities could a new review uncover? 

Turning Payer Analysis Into Better 2027 Financial Decisions

A payer profitability review should lead to action. Once healthcare leaders understand where revenue is being lost and where costs are rising, they can use those findings to guide their 2027 budgets.

Focus on these priorities:

  • Recover missed revenue. Investigate confirmed underpayments and pursue eligible claims within payer deadlines.
  • Reduce unnecessary work. Address recurring denials, billing errors, and follow-up processes that take time away from other priorities.
  • Strengthen contract negotiations. Use payment data and reimbursement trends to support requests for better contract terms and rates.
  • Improve financial planning. Use payer-specific collection patterns, payment timelines, and administrative costs to build more realistic budget forecasts.

Not every payer problem requires the same solution. Some organizations need to improve internal billing processes. Others may need help recovering underpayments or reviewing outdated contracts.

The important thing is to understand where each payer stands before making decisions about the year ahead.

With better information, healthcare leaders can protect revenue, use staff resources more effectively, and make stronger financial decisions for 2027.

The Questions Healthcare Executives Should Ask Before 2027

Before finalizing next year’s budget, CFOs, CEOs, and directors of finance should be able to answer several important questions:

  • Which payers generate the most reimbursement, and which contribute the greatest financial value after direct administrative costs?
  • Are actual payments consistent with contracted reimbursement rates?
  • Which payer relationships create the greatest denial, underpayment, and follow-up burden?
  • How much staff time is spent resolving payer-specific issues?
  • How do differences in service mix and delivery costs affect our comparisons? 
  • Which contracts warrant a closer review or a renegotiation strategy?
  • Do current reports reveal the underlying causes of reimbursement and administrative cost variances?

If these questions lack clear answers, the organization may not see enough to assess payer performance accurately. 

Existing billing reports and financial statements are a helpful starting point. But they may not show if each contract is performing as expected. They may also not explain why some payer relationships use disproportionate resources.

A focused analytical approach can link reimbursement data, contract terms, and revenue cycle operations to financial results leaders need. 

Evaluate Your Payer Relationships Before They Affect Your Bottom Line

Your largest payer may be an essential partner in delivering care. But you should evaluate its contribution to your organization using more than patient volume and total collections.

Understanding payer profitability requires a closer look at reimbursement accuracy, contract performance, administrative costs, and the operational demands associated with each relationship.

Legacy Consulting Services helps healthcare organizations review payer performance, find reimbursement errors, and study contract terms. We also identify ways to improve revenue cycle management efficiency. Through reimbursement assessing, payer contracting, audits, and revenue cycle consulting, Legacy provides deeper financial insight. Leaders use it to make informed decisions and strengthen organizational performance.

As you prepare your 2027 budget, ask if your current payer relationships deliver the financial results your organization needs.

Do you know which payer contracts are actually contributing to your organization’s profitability? Legacy Consulting Services can help you find out.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *